Hindsight Markets Beta

Hindsight Markets Help

Replay a trade from your journal

Every closed trade has its own page in the journal. From there you can trade the same moment again, watch it back with trading off, or see what other exits would have made. Take it again and Watch open Practice replays, so they never touch your Career. Replay the whole day, on a day's page, works another way: read its step before you click it.

Watch this guide as a video: Replay a trade from your journal Plays here, from YouTube, when you click.

Steps

  1. Click Journal in the left rail, then Trades, then the trade. If it is not in the list, switch Month to All time. A Practice trade shows under Practice or Both. The trade's page opens with its result, a line that starts Replay from, and the chart.
  2. Click Take it again to trade the same moment again. It opens a new Practice replay of that stock and day, thirty seconds before your entry, and takes you to it. It does not ask first, and it never reuses a replay you already have: each click opens another one. The replay you had open is paused. Press play when you are ready.
  3. Trade it as you like. Your first trade is hidden on the chart. Once you close a trade on that stock in this replay, the chart shows the first one grayed, and a line at the bottom left of the chart, starting You took, sets the two results side by side. Hide closes that line. To show or hide the first trade, click the chart's gear, then Events, then Show the original trade. These trades count as Practice, and their page reads Practice with the attempt, such as Attempt 2.
  4. Or click Watch to see the moment again with trading off. It opens a Watch replay of that stock, thirty seconds before your entry, named Watching with the stock and the day. Your fills, stop and best price are drawn on the chart, grayed, each once the clock reaches it. Every way to send an order answers Watching. Trading is off in this session. Nothing in it goes to your journal. Watch on any trade of the same stock and day brings back that same Watch replay, moved to the new moment.
  5. Click What if to see what other exits would have made. Your exit is what your trade made before fees. The rows under it price the same shares closed another way: Sold at the best price while you were in, Held 5 more minutes, Held 15 more minutes, Held 30 more minutes, Best exit in the 30 minutes after you left, Stopped at your planned stop and Held for your planned target. Every figure is before fees, and its bar shows its size against the others. Where the trade has an R, point at a figure to read it in R. Try one in the replay, under the rows, does what Take it again does.
  6. Read the chart on the trade's page. On 1 min, where it starts until you pick another, it is framed around your trade. The triangles are your entry and exit, each with its shares and price. A dashed line is your stop, labeled with its price and 1R, and a second one is your planned target, if you set one. A hollow circle marks the best price while you were in. Through and a time, above the chart, is as far as the chart is drawn.
  7. Click 5 min or Daily for a wider view, and VWAP, 9 EMA, SPY or Tape at each fill to add a line. 5 min shows the day with your trade's minutes shaded. Daily shows the days before it with the trade's day shaded, and has no VWAP or Tape at each fill. VWAP is on to start. SPY starts on the candles and moves by SPY's percent, so you can see if the stock went with the market. Tape at each fill marks, at each fill, the bid and the ask when your order arrived. This browser keeps your choices.
  8. For the whole day, click Calendar in the journal's sidebar, then the day, then Replay the whole day. A day traded only in Practice shows with Practice or Both chosen. Replay the whole day opens on the day's first traded stock. It does not ask first and does not start the day over. If you already have a replay of that date, it takes you back to one where you left it: first a replay that holds only that stock, which can be a Take it again or a Watch replay, else your replay of that date, a Career day included, with the stock added. A trade you place there counts the way that replay counts. Only with no replay of that date does it open a new Practice replay, at 4:00 in the morning, New York time, even if new replays start later for you.
  9. To come back to the trade's page, press your browser's back button. Journal in the left rail, or G then J, opens the journal's Overview instead. On the trade's page, ← Back goes back to where you came from, and the arrows at the top right step to the previous and next trade.
One trade's page in the journal: ALIT long 500 on 2026-11-04, its result in dollars and in R, the one-minute chart with the entry, the exit and the stop marked, the notes box and the grade.

The Trades view at a glance

The journal's Trades view with Practice and Month chosen, listing three trades, and eight parts numbered: the period with its arrows, the filters, Career, Practice and Both, Week, Month and All time, the unit, Columns, Compare and the trades.
  1. The period's name, with ‹ and › either side. With Week or Month chosen they step back or forward one week or one month.
  2. The filters that are always on screen: Result, Playbook and Mistake. More filters, at the right end of the row, opens the rest.
  3. Career, Practice, Both: whose trades you read. Career is your record and Practice is every other replay trade. Practice is chosen here.
  4. Week, Month, All time: the period. A trade is filed under the market day you replayed, not the day you sat at the desk.
  5. The unit: $ reads results in dollars, and R reads them as a multiple of what you risked.
  6. Columns opens the column picker above the table.
  7. Compare opens Compare over the same trades.
  8. One row for each closed trade, newest exit first. Click a row to open the trade's page.

A day's page at a glance

The journal's page for one traded day, with the day's result, its trades, the empty fields for notes, the grade letters and the fold named The replay, and eight parts numbered: the day's result, the Trades list, Replay the whole day, the note fields, Your grade for the day, the Calendar link, the Week of link and The replay.
  1. The day's result. The line under the date counts the day's trades, how many won and lost, and the fees. The large figure at the right is what the day made or lost after fees.
  2. Trades: the day's trades. Click one to open its page.
  3. Replay the whole day opens that day's replay.
  4. The four fields to write the day up in: Before the open, After, What to fix and One rule for next time. There is no save button. The page saves as you type and reads Saved.
  5. Your grade for the day. Click a letter.
  6. ← Calendar goes back to the Calendar, on this day's month.
  7. Week of 2 Nov, the link at the top right, opens the page of the week this day is in.
  8. The replay, at the foot of the page. Click it to read the day's replays back: Replay P&L as a curve, with Peak, Gave back, Trades and In the market, and the stock's chart with your trades marked on it.

Good to know

Next guide Read your journal stats