A day trading journal that writes itself, and a track record that counts
In Hindsight Markets, every trade you take in a replay lands in your journal with its executions, its slippage against the book, and how far it went for you and against you. Your Career is a running account across days where a stock's day counts once, so the results mean something. Everything else is Practice, kept beside it and never counted in your Career.
This page is about the journal and the record. For the replay itself, see stock market replay; for the morning's runners, the small-cap day trading simulator; for everything the day trading simulator does, start at the home page.
Career and Practice
- Career. A named account with its own balance that carries from day to day. The balance is where it started plus what its trades made or lost. Open a stock's day you have not seen as a Career day, trade it, and the result goes on your record.
- Practice. Everything else. A stock's day you have already seen, in a replay or in a trade you imported, a different balance or leverage, or a career with no money left opens as Practice, and the Open dialog says why in one line.
- One open day at a time. If a Career day still has a position or orders working, the app shows it before the next Career day opens: go back to it, or close it and open the new one.
- Going back. Until your first order, rewind a Career day freely: only trading earlier than you have already watched asks first, and makes the day Practice. After an order, going back opens a watch-only copy at that time while your Career day waits where you left it, with a way back or the choice to trade there as Practice. Reset account asks first, closes what you hold into your Career, and the rest of the session is Practice.
- Your own careers. Start a new career at the balance and leverage you choose, and keep more than one. The amount can change until its first trade; after that a different amount is a new career.
- History stays. Archive a career, or run one down to nothing, and its trades stay in the journal.
The trade page
Every trade opens on its own page: the chart of that day with your trade drawn on it, its numbers, its fills, and what it would have made had you done something else.
- What if. What the same trade would have made had you held on longer, sold at the best price while you were in, been stopped at your planned stop, or held for your planned target.
- Back at that moment. Open a trade and you are back thirty seconds before you were in. Watch it with your fills drawn on the chart, trading off, or take it again. The first attempt is the one that counts; every attempt after it is Practice, numbered and shown beside the original.
Review it your way
- R. Set a stop, on the order or after the close, and every result reads in R. The position size calculator works out the size from that stop, and risk and reward explains the arithmetic.
- Playbooks. Write your playbooks and their rules, then see how the trades that followed each rule did against the ones that did not.
- Mistakes and grades. Tag a trade's mistakes from a starter list or in your own words, and grade it A to F.
- Plans. Each trade keeps its plan, the stop and the target, and says whether you followed it: the stop held, the stop moved, the target hit or missed.
- What pays. Break your results down by playbook, time of day, weekday, hold time, symbol, mistake or grade. Compare one week or month against another, or your results with and without a playbook, a tag or a symbol.
- Notes. Each day has its own notes, before the open and after, with what to fix and one rule for tomorrow; each week has its notes and a grade. One search runs over your trade notes, your day and week notes and each playbook's description.
- Patterns. It flags the revenge trade, the overtrading, the loser you held and the broken plan, and shows your totals with and without the flagged trades.
- Drawdowns and trends. Every fall from a high, how deep it went in dollars and in R, and when it recovered. How often you win, your expectancy, and your best and worst while in, as rolling lines.
- The shuffle test. Your same trades, put in a different order again and again, show how deep a drawdown each order would have given you, with your real order marked. It says what share of the shuffles fell deeper than you did, and what share had a losing run as long as yours.
Bring in your real trades
- Import. Drop in your broker's own export, or a CSV of fills with date, time, symbol, quantity, price and side. The app recognises the file, pairs the fills into round trips, and shows you the trades and anything it skipped before you import them.
- Kept apart. Imported trades sit beside your replay trades in their own group, without mixing into them, and never count toward your Career.
- Back at that moment. Open an imported trade from a day from August 2026 forward and you are back thirty seconds before you were in, to watch it or take it again. Once a stock's day is in your imports, a replay of it is Practice.
- Export everything. Your trades as a CSV you can import again, or everything as one file: trades, fills, numbers and notes.
A replay result is a practice result: your fills are simulated against that day's real book, and what the model does not capture is on the disclaimer page. Read is paper trading realistic for where the gap is, slippage for what the slippage column measures, and going from paper trading to live for how to use a record like this before real money. Finding the stock is on the scanner simulator page, and getting in and out on the hotkeys, orders and shorting page.
Common questions
- What is the difference between Career and Practice?
- Career is your record: a stock's day counts in it once, on a balance that carries from day to day. Practice is everything else, kept beside it in the journal and never counted in your Career.
- Do I have to write up my trades?
- No. Every replay trade is journaled with its fills, slippage and how far it went for and against you. Notes, mistakes, grades and playbooks are yours to add when you want them.
- Can I redo a trade?
- Yes. Open it and take it again from thirty seconds before you were in. The new attempt is Practice, shown beside the original and never counted in your Career.
- Can I import my live trades?
- Yes, from your broker's own export or a CSV of fills with their dates and times. They stay in their own group, apart from your replay trades.
- Can I take my data with me?
- Yes. Export your trades as a CSV you can import again, or everything as one file of trades, fills, numbers and notes.
Start a record on a real past day
Pick a morning, trade it as it happened with simulated money, and the journal does the rest.