Common questions
These are the questions people ask before they start with Hindsight Markets and while they use it. Each item is named for a question, and the answer under it is a few sentences. The page covers what you need to run the app, which days and stocks it covers, what it says while something loads, how to get help, and what happens with money and your data.
How to use this page
Find your question in the list of sections below, or search the page for a word from it. Each answer says what the app does today, in the words the app and this site use. Where another help page has the detail, the answer ends with a link to it. If your question is not here, write to [email protected].
What you need
- Do I need to install anything? No. Hindsight Markets runs in a web browser, and there is nothing to download. Open the site, sign up or log in, and the app opens in that browser.
- Do I need a broker account or a market data plan? No. There is nothing to connect, and everything you see is included. Every order is simulated against historical market data, and no order reaches an exchange or a broker.
- Which browsers can I use? Google Chrome or Microsoft Edge, on a computer. Hindsight Markets is built and tested for those two. Other browsers may work, but they are not tested, and Firefox and Safari cannot put windows back on your other monitors. What you need: computer, screen and browser.
- What depends on my browser? A few things, and the app says so in each place. Window placement, under Layouts in Replay settings, lets windows return to the monitor you left them on. It needs a browser that lets a site place windows on your other monitors, and where the browser cannot, the row reads: This browser can only open windows on the main monitor. A browser that blocks pop-ups opens one window for each click. The app then says Some windows didn't open and offers Reopen windows, and allowing pop-ups for this site in your browser's settings ends that. The Say the symbol sound needs a browser that can speak, and where it cannot, the sound list reads: Say the symbol (not in this browser). App settings and layouts.
- Does it work on a phone or a tablet? It opens on both, and it is best on a computer. The app is a desk of windows side by side. A browser window narrower than 768 pixels gets the phone layout: one view of a replay at a time, with a strip to trade from. A tablet whose browser window is 768 pixels wide or wider gets the desk, the same as a computer. On a phone.
- How many screens can I use? Up to 8. A screen is a desk of its own, with its own windows. The plus button after your screen tabs adds a New screen or an Empty screen. Open in a window, in a screen's menu, moves a screen to its own browser window, so your desk can spread across several monitors. At the limit the app says: You have the maximum of 8 screens. Close one to add another. A phone has no screens. Arrange your desk.
- Is my work saved if I close the tab? Yes. A replay you leave is paused on the server, and its clock, positions and orders are kept. Open it again from the Replays sidebar and it resumes where you left off. A trade is in your journal from the moment it closes. Saved layouts, hotkeys and order entry settings are kept on your account. Your screens and the arrangement you last left them in are kept in the browser you used, so save a layout to have it in another browser. A guest's work is kept for 30 days after the last visit, and only the browser that started it can open it. App settings and layouts.
- What happens to a replay I leave open? A replay nobody is using is put to sleep, to free its place on the servers. Before that, after a long time with no mouse or keyboard in any window of the app, a box headed Still there? says how long is left. Click I'm here, move the mouse or press a key, and the replay stays awake. A replay that went to sleep says: Your clock, positions and orders are kept. Resume to pick up where you left off. When something goes wrong.
What is covered
The rules in a replay are those of the day you replay, at the time the clock is on. The glossary explains each one.
- Which days can I open? Every trading day from August 2026 forward. A weekend or a day the market was closed has no session to replay. An older date is refused with a line that starts Replays start from August 2026. A day cannot be opened on the day itself, by the New York calendar, and the dialog says: Today isn't available yet. It opens tomorrow. A guest can open only the most recent trading days, and the dialog says which. Open a past market day.
- When is a new day ready? Each new trading day is added overnight. While the newest day is still being prepared, the calendar keeps it gray, and a line under Replay date says so, as in Tuesday, Nov 10 isn't ready yet. We're still preparing it. Once a day is running late the line reads is taking longer than usual. and can go on to name what is still to come. Pick an earlier day, or open the dialog again later. When something goes wrong.
- Can I use it at night or on weekends? Yes. The days are recorded, so the market is open whenever you are. The clock in a replay shows the time of the day you replay, in New York time.
- Which stocks are covered, and what is not? Every stock, ETF and warrant listed on a US exchange. OTC stocks are not included. When the app holds no data for a ticker on the day you picked, the Open replay dialog says so, as in No data for ABCD on 2026-11-04. The symbol may not have traded that day, or the ticker is unknown.
- Do I pick one stock for a replay? No. A replay is the whole market on one day. Switch stocks from a scanner, a watchlist or the search box as often as you like, and your account and your profit and loss follow you. Find a stock that is moving.
- Can I trade pre-market and after-hours? Yes. A replay's day runs from 04:00 to 20:00 New York time. That covers the pre-market, the regular session and after-hours, and the order book, the tape and the scanners run through all of it. Outside the regular session of the day you replay, a market order is not accepted, and the order ticket tells you to use a limit order. Pre-market trading.
- Are the halts real? Yes. The halts in a replay are the ones that happened that day, taken from the exchanges' own halt messages. Level 2 and Time & sales show a halt while it lasts. A market order sent during a halt does not fill, and a limit order rests until trading resumes. LULD halt.
- Is the short sale restriction real? Yes. It comes from the flag the exchanges published that day, so it switches on in a replay when it did in the market. While it is on, the top of Level 2 shows SSR, and a market short or a short limit at or under the bid is refused with the reason. A short limit above the bid rests. Selling shares you hold is not affected. The short sale restriction (SSR).
- Is the borrow status real? Yes. It is read from that day's borrow data, as it stood at the time the clock is on. Beside the ticker at the top of Level 2, S is easy to borrow, HTB is hard to borrow and NTB is no shares to borrow. A stock marked S needs no locate. A short on a hard-to-borrow stock is refused until you buy a locate in the Short locate window, and a stock with no shares to borrow cannot be shorted. Hard to borrow and locates.
- Is the order book real? Yes. Level 2, the tape and the charts are built from every trade and every change to the order book on the US exchanges that day, recorded as it happened. A market order takes only the size that was showing, best price first, and a limit order waits its turn in the real queue at its exchange. Level 2.
- What can the fills not model? The disclaimer page has the full list. A marketable order, which is one priced to trade at once, fills only against the size on display, so one bigger than that size gets a partial. Hidden size is not modeled, so size you cannot see never fills you. Off-exchange trades never fill a marketable order. During regular hours, an off-exchange trade priced through your resting limit fills it at your limit price, and one at your limit price does not. Off-exchange trades can also trigger your stops. Slippage is modeled to the depth you can see, and your own order moving the market afterwards is not. Slippage.
- Is it a backtester? No. You trade by hand, at market speed or faster, as you would on a real trading day. Nothing here runs a strategy for you.
When the app is slow
While the app loads or rebuilds something, it says what it is doing, in these words.
- Why does a stock take about a minute to open? The first time a stock is opened on a day, its order book is loaded for that day. The Open replay dialog says so, as in Loading ABCD for 2026-11-04. About a minute. The Open button reads Check again while it loads. Leave the dialog open: the app checks by itself every few seconds, and the replay opens when the stock is ready. When something goes wrong.
- What does Getting your replay ready… mean? The servers are finding room for your replay, and the app keeps trying by itself for a few minutes. When the servers are full, the dialog says so in a sentence, with a countdown under it that starts Trying again in. Room comes free when a replay is closed or paused. When something goes wrong.
- What do Loading and Catching up mean on a window? Both show beside the ticker in a window's symbol box, and both clear by themselves. Loading and the ticker, as in Loading ABCD…, means a stock you typed is being added to the replay. Catching up… means the stock is being rebuilt to the time the clock is on, while the rest of the replay keeps playing. If a stock cannot be added, a bar under the replay controls reads Couldn't load and the ticker, with a Retry button. The bar can give the reason, such as: The server is full right now, so it can't load another symbol. Try again in a minute. When something goes wrong.
- What happens when I jump to another time? The order book is rebuilt at the new time. The bar along the bottom of the screen reads Seeking…, and the order ticket reads: Rebuilding the book at the new time. Order entry arms when it lands. If that part of the day has not arrived yet, the bar reads Loading this part of the day…, and the windows that show the book read This part of the day hasn't loaded yet. It fills in by itself. A replay you open at a later start time shows Loading… over the desk while it moves there. Play, pause, jump and rewind the day.
- How many stocks can one replay hold at once? A replay keeps a limited number of stocks loaded at once. A stock counts while it is on a window, holds a position or a working order, or has an armed price alert. A stock past the limit is not loaded, and its window's symbol box reads Symbol limit. Hover those words for the sentence, which names the limit, as in: You can keep 6 symbols live at once. Close a panel, a position or an alert on another symbol to bring this one in. An order that would open a position on one stock too many is refused with a sentence that starts You already have and ends: Close one of them to trade a new symbol.
- What changes when I run the replay faster? The speeds are 0.5, 1, 2, 3, 5 and 10 times. Your fills do not change with speed. Model limits, under Order entry in Replay settings, puts it this way: Speed changes the view, never the fills. What changes is how far the replay has moved by the time your click lands. A Scanner window ranks the market again each time a minute of the replay closes, and at fast speeds minutes close faster than a scan can run. Its stamp then says how many were skipped, as in · 3 bars not scanned. Slow the replay down to rank every minute. Play, pause, jump and rewind the day.
Getting help
- How do I reach you? Write to [email protected] with a question, a bug or an idea, and say what you were trying to do. The address is at the foot of every page of this site.
- What does Send feedback send? Send feedback is in the account menu, behind the round button with your initials at the foot of the left rail. On a phone it is under the More tab. It opens a box that says: It goes straight to the person who builds this. Your message takes up to 4,000 characters, and Attach an image takes one PNG, JPEG or WebP file of up to 2 MB. Under What I was doing the box lists what goes with your message. The lines are Surface, Page, Symbol, Replay date, Replay clock, Last order, Fill convention, Release and Browser, and a line with nothing to say is left out. Click Clear to send your message without them. Click Send, and the box answers: Sent. Thank you. Your account.
- Is there a community? Yes. The foot of every page of this site links our Discord, beside our YouTube, Instagram, TikTok and X accounts. In the app, the Send feedback box and the Keyboard shortcuts sheet have a Community link to our Discord.
- Where do I read what a message means? The page When something goes wrong lists the app's messages by the words on screen, with what each one means and what to do next. It covers a day that will not open, a lost connection, a refused order, a hotkey that does nothing, a trade missing from the journal and a scanner that shows nothing. When something goes wrong.
- Where are the help pages inside the app? Help guides, in the account menu, opens these pages in a new browser tab, so your desk stays as it is. The Keyboard shortcuts sheet, which the ? key opens, has the same link under Help and feedback. Hotkey settings and keyboard shortcuts.
Money and data
- Is it real money? No. Every order is simulated against historical market data. No real money changes hands, no order reaches an exchange or a broker, and no position you hold here exists anywhere else. Nothing here is financial advice.
- Is it free? Hindsight Markets is in beta, and the home page says: Free while we're in beta. No card needed.
- Can I bring in my real trades? Yes. Import your broker's export and your trades land in the journal, kept apart from your practice. For any day from August 2026 on, you can open the market that day and go back to the moment you were in. Bring in your broker's trades.
- How do I get a copy of my trades? Click Export at the foot of the journal's sidebar. It opens a dialog headed Export your data, with one download of everything and one CSV file of your trades. Both cover your whole journal, whatever filters are on screen. Journal settings.
- Can I turn analytics off? Yes. The Privacy tab of User Settings has Turn off and Turn on, under a line that says where things stand. The choice is kept in the browser you set it in, so set it again in each browser you use. Where the app has no analytics set up, the tab has no buttons and reads: This app isn't using analytics right now. Your account.
- How do I delete my data? Open User Settings and go to the Danger zone tab. Start over deletes every replay, trade, note and career, and keeps your login, settings, layouts, scanners and watchlists. Delete Account deletes the account and everything on it. Each asks first, and neither can be undone. You can also email us to see or remove your data. Your account.
Good to know
- Times in a replay are New York time, the time of the day you replay, on a 24-hour clock.
- Session hours, the short sale restriction, halts and borrow are those of the day you replay, at the time the clock is on. The glossary explains each rule.
- A profit or a loss in a replay says something about a decision against that day's order book. It is not a prediction of what the same decision would do with real money.
- Send feedback is in three places: the account menu, the Keyboard shortcuts sheet that the ? key opens, and Search and commands.
- If your question is not on this page, write to [email protected] and say what you were trying to do.